Free Claude skill
Claude tends to say yes to your idea. This skill puts it on trial instead.
Free with an account. No password: you get a login link by email, and it stays in your library.
Claude writes a short case file: the idea, who it is for, how it makes money, how customers find it and what they use today. If two or more are missing it asks at most three questions. Anything still unknown is written down as an assumption.
A prosecutor argues it will fail, a defender argues it will work. They run as separate agents and only see the case file, never each other's brief. At most five points each, with what every point rests on and what would disprove it.
Each juror gets the case file, both briefs and its own role, and never another juror's vote. Every vote is guilty or not guilty, with a confidence from 1 to 5, one deciding reason and the one thing that would flip it.
Twelve points of view, so the downsides get argued too.
A judge reads everything and counts the not guilty votes. It may overrule the tally only by naming the exact charge or argument that decides it.
One short verdict, not a wall of text. This is the shape every ruling comes in. Ask for the transcript if you want both briefs and all 12 votes.
Verdict
Build it / Fix first / Drop it
Jury: n not guilty, n guilty
Why it can work
Why it could fail
Fix these first
At most three concrete changes.
Cheapest test this week
One experiment that would change the verdict, and what counts as a pass.
idea-court folder in ~/.claude/skills/ for every project, or in .claude/skills/ inside one project./idea-court.unzip ~/Downloads/idea-court.zip -d ~/.claude/skills/Each juror runs as its own agent, so the vote is actually blind.
The roles are played one by one in the same chat, so the blind vote is simulated and less independent.
The court only knows what you tell it. Numbers you do not provide are treated as assumptions and labelled that way, never invented. The lawyer on the jury is a point of view, not legal advice.
49 USDBundle · BusinessEverything BundleEvery paid skill pack, kit, guide and prompt library in one download, for about half of what they cost on their own.
29 USDKit · ProductivityClaude Code Kit for FoundersA practical setup for shipping with Claude Code: a step-by-step guide, CLAUDE.md templates, safe permission settings, hooks and five developer skills.
9 USDSkill pack · Business10 Claude Skills for Solo FoundersTen ready-to-install Claude skills for running a one-person business.
19 USDKit · MarketingContent Engine KitSix Claude skills, a weekly workflow, a content calendar and 60 hook patterns to plan, write and repurpose content without starting from zero.